Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Like a pink batt out of hell, Garrett absorbs the heat 

Like a pink batt out of hell, Garrett absorbs the heat

Environment Minister Peter Garrett's departmental officials grilled over safety concerns with home insulation program.

The security scanners at Parliament House, through which all visitors must pass, are emblazoned with the same name as the embattled Environment Minister: ''Garrett'' they say, in bright yellow.

It is appropriate that the portals of the nation's great house should share Peter Garrett's name at this time, when he has become the ritual sacrifice, no less than a Mayan virgin, on the altar of high stakes politics.

The very walls of Parliament seem to whisper his name. ''Garrett'' is on lips in the canteen, in the corridors, in the sun-drenched courtyards and in the cool committee room, 2S3, where the Environment Department's secretaries were being grilled yesterday morning over the failed home-insulation scheme the government was forced to suspend on Friday.

Will he stay or will he go, is what everyone wants to know.

The departmental secretary, Robyn Kruk, defended her minister: ''There is only one way of ensuring a risk-free environment [and that is] not to go into ceilings.''

Garrett laboured the same line later in question time.

''We take safety seriously … The construction of the risk-management program and framework under the home insulation program was particularly and specifically designed to that end.''

But the opposition wasn't buying. It wants a propitiatory offering from the government to pay for four deaths, 1000 electrified roofs, 93 house fires, and what it says are 160,000 dodgy installations.

The opposition's environment spokesman, Greg Hunt, named the four young installers whose deaths must be atoned for. The Opposition Leader, Tony Abbott, called for Garrett's resignation as part of a censure motion. ''You show no remorse, no concern, no urgency about anything except saving your own hide … If the Minister had a shred of the conscience he so exemplified in his former life [he would be] probing his own soul.''

The Prime Minister was there but curiously detached, as if he had more important things on his mind - like fussing with the highlighted pages and plastic sleeves and ring-binders in front of him. He arranged them and rearranged them so it seemed in the end as if he were playing a ritualised form of solitaire.

When Garrett stood at the dispatch box to answer the barrage of questions from the opposition, amid catcalls of ''Roofgate'' and ''blah blah blah'', Rudd busied himself with a pink highlighter.

''This Prime Minister is more than likely … in this program up to his neck,'' Abbott said. But it was Garrett who was losing skin.

His long supple legs and elegant fingers might be those of an artist, but his voice, as it droned impassively throughout question time, making procedural point after procedural point, showed the heart of a bureaucrat. ''I acted on the basis of that advice and on the basis of that advice I put the measures in place which we rolled out in terms of delivering the home insulation program.'' He has learnt well from his boss.

The opposition wants his scalp. But Garrett is the government's human pink batt, insulating Rudd and his cabinet from the heat. For no other reason he's hanging on.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Garrett can't probe his soul - he sold it when he joined the Labor Party.
Posted by bill, 23/02/2010 12:49:21 PM
This is a beat-up of the worse kind. The opposition is also playing politics with things that it ought not to. All insulation materials used in the past and today has to conform to standards set by the appropriate authorities. Any employer, who employs a person has to provide a safe work environment. Any employer has to ensure that staff are qualified for the job they do. The roll-out of the program may have caused a shortage of qualified people, but that is no excuse for employing unqualified staff. Licensed installers are responsible for their own actions. If a soldier in Afghanistan does something stupid and gets killied or maimed, is the defense minister responsible? Is the health minister responsible for mistakes in hospitals? Why do we take "the buck stops with me" so literrally when we all know it is an euphemism for "the buck stops below me". Have the inquests for the four people been concluded. Have the 93 house fires been investigated. Have the 160,000 'dodgy' installations been verified as such, or are they just a statistical fancy? If we were able to inspect 160,000 homes and declare them dodgy in such a short time, how about installers inspecting to begin with.
Posted by David Klein, 23/02/2010 4:23:12 PM
Personally , I think Garret`s a major w**ker , however with regards the insulation uproar , how the hell is He responsible for the stupidity or criminal neglect of the installers . Who , in their right mind would think stapling aluminium foil to a power cable is a good idea ? If the people who died were tradesmen then they bloody well should have known better , if they were kids or apprentices with little or no training then the businesses employing them need to be charged with criminal negligence as a MINIMUM !!
Posted by Waylander, 23/02/2010 6:08:34 PM
It's not just the insulation disaster but the whole climate change program delivery that has seen the Rudd government censured in the Senate. Fielding called it right when he play-acted his role today in saying wacky greens causing a wacky Labor agenda. What a bloody mess, starting with Rudd and his supposedly top ministers they couldn't run a pizza oven and this circus must be the laughing stock of the world. Come to think of it every aussie is paying way to much for their seat too. Can't wait for the circus to leave town so somebody can clean up the mess.
Posted by Charlie, 23/02/2010 8:16:29 PM
Great article Melinda
Posted by JJ, 24/02/2010 5:22:14 PM
please retire from journalism miss devine and run for liberal party headquarters president.
Posted by micky, 24/02/2010 9:17:59 PM
The Government rushed the scheme out without any thought or planning . They ignored many warnings from those who know .The Government said they wanted to save the economy . There was nothing wrong with our Economy until Wayne Swan presented the people of Australia with Gloom and Doom messages about the Global Financial mess overseas and then raised interest rates not long after they came into Government .The Government wanted to slow down our economy , and they did .People stopped spending money . Now this Labor Government has been spending money like drunken sailors ever since ! Will a new school hall make kids brighter ? No The Labor Government needs an excuse to increase taxes . So we hear spins about that the environment needs to be saved and we have to increase taxes by bringing in the ETS TAX scam . We all know it wont do a thing except bleed out pockets of money so that Kevin Rudd can have a field day of wasting more taxpayer dollars . I am disappointed that our local member for the seat of Lyne is supporting the Labor Government with this ETS TAX scam only to put more financial hardship on the people in his Electorate . Does he really care ?
Posted by NIKI , 26/02/2010 11:28:21 AM
Charlie yes! I think most discerning people can't wait for the circus to leave town. Sadly, the mess and debris which will be left won't be able to be cleaned quickly. If any one of us were to lift just a corner of a piece of the debris, we would see another concealed layer, another frightening dimension. Usually people smile and laugh when the circus is in town but the Rudd Government is no laughing matter and I for one, have not enjoyed the circus thus far and it's cost me (AND YOU PEOPLE OUT THERE) lots of money and for some, much heartache. I muse when I hear Kevin Rudd say "I accept full responsibilty" and then he, in the same breath, proceeds to blame all and sundry. SPIN has worn thin and every circus has a starting and finishing time and then the show is over and it moves on. Sometimes we're sad about that, but this time I can't wait for them all to pack up and hit the road to the next Town named, Oblivian!
Posted by Anne, 26/02/2010 2:49:23 PM
Electrified roof from insulation? My house roof was electrified by feedback from my TV through the power point & aerial. After several electricians & roofers studied the problem, it took a retired electrician who had only seen it once before to correctly identify the problem. I found it by touching the downpipe & receiving a shock.
Posted by tina, 27/02/2010 2:25:33 PM
How many thousand houses before the insulation rebate started have pink batts in their ceilings? How many people were electrecuted while putting pink batts in the ceiling? the answer is very simple NIL. How many people died putting in foil insulation? answer 4 How many houses caught fire with foil as the sulation? 93 Like everything the Government blames all insulation. Media blam pink batts. Metal foil insulation is used in cold rooms, Frigerators, freezes where there is no power. Foil or metal is a very good conductor of electricity just have a look at the power lines they are metal.
Posted by Boney, 28/02/2010 7:13:37 PM
1 | 2  |  next >
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!
Federal Minister for the Environment, Peter Garrett
Federal Minister for the Environment, Peter Garrett

Most popular articles




Southern Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...